Page 2 of 4
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 8:11 am
by jamesd74
The first on gets my vote...
Today I will do another chord progression...
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 9:14 am
by polyal
Olly wrote:post removed
thanks for removing clips ..can you sort out uploading with google chrome
..the problem with 3rd party uploads is...edits / mods and esp comments
cant be added to the post ( by the author )
will upload fast version again ASAP
+is there anyway of downloading a clip as an mp3 straight from a posting???
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 9:23 am
by Olly
I will try and look for a better upload method today.
Just drop the tags I sent you into your post for now then you will be able to edit comments etc.
At the moment there is no simple way of downloading the MP3 - I can look into this.
The issue with allowing direct uploads is that it opens up a load of security issues within the server. So I will try and relax the rulings a little without creating too much risk.
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 10:01 am
by Olly
It looks like this problem with Chrome could have been around for a while
http://www.google.co.uk/support/forum/p ... 20cb&hl=en
I just downloaded the latest version and successfully uploaded 2 x MP3s no problem. So if you are using Chrome can you update to the latest version and try again?
Thanks
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 10:58 am
by polyal
downloaded v17 chrome...still no joy
what version of chrome have you got?
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 11:05 am
by Olly
Can you send me that exact file you attempted and I will try this on my Chrome - v17.0.963.79 m
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 4:08 pm
by polyal
well done olley...google chrome v17...etc now works
[mp3]/uploads/7a8598551c9ef51bc1366f537e68ec95.mp3[/mp3]
orig guit C/// C/// Cmaj7/// //// Am/// //// //// //// x2
[mp3]/uploads/06939e5441c14c2be6097b517d4a65c7.mp3[/mp3]
original guit with bass and drums ( fast )
the whole point is..two separate people collaborated to get this ( pop type feel )
it can now be taken further / altered / added to...whatever by other people
or the original can be treated completely different
[mp3]/uploads/82c4a6e42629d8621312e37c71897c81.mp3[/mp3]
slow version....these are just tryouts so anything can be changed
so if someones got a country/blues/jazz/folk ...etc idea get it posted
and let other people contribute ideas
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 4:51 pm
by Olly
Glad it is all working again.
Is that guitar in the slow version the same tempo as the orig or did you slow it slightly? I can imagine that the reason it sounds slower is just because of the drums and bass giving it that feel?
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 6:01 pm
by polyal
the guitar is exactly the same in both versions ...
the bass and drums are played to give the required feel
to give the desired results ( fast/slow)
in cubase they are both done with a setting of 132 Bpm
the fast one is 4/4 (4 beats per bar) the slow one 2/4 ( 2 beats per bar )
so the slow one is exactly 1/2 the speed of the fast one
if cubase ( or any daw ) was set to 66Bpm
then the slow one would be 4/4 (4 beats per bar ) and the fast one 8/4 ( 8 beats per bar )
ie the fast would be exactly 2x the speed of the slow one
in either case everything would sound exactly the same
import the 2 versions into your daw ...line them up to start on the bar
and try these tempos 33 66 132 264 set the metronome to 4/4 and listen to the click
even though the tempos have changed the speed remains the same
you could record it at 264Bpm but to get the same results (speed ) you would have to record
at 1/4 ( 1 beat per bar ) and 2/4 ( 2 beats per bar )
perhaps someone has got a better way of explaining it but thats how i see it
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:03 pm
by jamesd74
All looks good so come on lets have some more input.
Have you done anything with it Olly??????????????????
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:10 pm
by Olly
No James. I really don't have a clue where to go from here. This is my stumbling block zone so I am watching with great interest on how it can be taken from this idea, into a song
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:22 pm
by jamesd74
We could do with a lead line.....
Its just a idea, but it works for me......I loop the loop and plug me axe in and just play till I get some thing.....I learnt this from Uni when you have writing block-----pick up a pen and start to write anything that is related.
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:26 pm
by polyal
RE tempo issue
[mp3]/uploads/e08518e765d6ecdfadf89f559310aced.mp3[/mp3]33bpm
[mp3]/uploads/116ef1b6aa95be003d841839c20a77f8.mp3[/mp3]66bpm
[mp3]/uploads/18aa5639fb6ecc856db3d5b660fc046d.mp3[/mp3]128bpm
[mp3]/uploads/db3beb37d0dffa0b48c9b5e1ec132814.mp3[/mp3]256bpm
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:51 pm
by polyal
a song writer usually thinks of a melody / lyrics then puts the chord structure round it
or something similar to that...this approach is to write a backing that might give a
songwriter some inspiration to write a melody to ...( most songwriters i know can do this ) so before all the bells and whistles a 1/2 decent chord progression is needed to base everything else on.
this is why input will give it a chance...else come on james get your thinking cap on
we've got the intro C Cmaj7 Am..I bet theres loads of talent on the forum but recording and posting
mp3's is a no no
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 8:29 pm
by Olly
I put in the track in Cubase and added some drums, looped it and just put a tiny bit of acoustic over the top (I'm really not set up for this).
But this is the same as I am always up to - exactly this point. I try to think about where it could go next, try thinking up a melody but in the end I just end up noodling with no direction over the fret board until I get bored.
So I think it will be massively beneficial for me to see how you guys move beyond this step.
And whilst I don't think I will specifically be able to contribute much to this collaboration, I am working along with it at every step of the way!
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 8:30 pm
by Olly
So what would you guys consider this part - is it purely the intro, is it the start of a verse as well?
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 9:56 pm
by jamesd74
I am open would be interested to hear the acoustic ... Would give me a better idea...
I always start with a chord progression sometimes it doesn't even stay.
Strangely enough I am good at lyrics but leave the melody to my mate.....I seem to just follow the chords. Where as me pal comes up with a melody that fits but does not follow the chords. That works for us..
As for the bpm. I see this song been about a man or a woman who wants to be with a partner they can not have. So ballady, yet, I did a clean sample in the hope of Alun and ricky B joining in. I would like to keep the song moving so my vote is 132.
As for Olly's block.....I have a big poster (in a frame) in the room of John Lennon. Although I am worshiper of everything that is ACDC our John was a fellow dyslexic. This I find a pure inspiration. Maybe Olly You just need to find your inspiration..
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 8:26 am
by Olly
jamesd74 wrote:Maybe Olly You just need to find your inspiration..
Maybe James though even when I feel inspired I cannot get past this initial barrier of taking an idea one stage forward.
Maybe once I got the ball rolling, I would be ok.
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 8:40 am
by jamesd74
It sounds daft.....but this can't get a project moving, is very similar to how a dyslexic like me is proven to feel when in education......
"I have a picture in my mind that I want to paint.....I put brush in paint lift paint to canvass and nothing"
A quote from a book I read about dyslexia.....
So if I sound condescending I don't mean to. I can relate to this more than you think.
Again the advise I can give "when you have writers block, write"
On a side note when I went to school which feels like another life now, I as told I was "thick" daily and "never amount to nothing". It is scientifically proven that Dyslexics use more of there brains, on average 12%. Have higher IQs then average mines 129 and are extremely creative in all ways of thinking....
And they called me thick..
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 8:45 am
by Olly
It is possible that I could have some form of music writing dyslexia if that even exists!
The difference is, is that I don't have a picture in my mind to start with. I'm trying to seek inspiration from the foundation, in this case the initial chord progression, and generally I have no problem being inspired to lay down an initial idea like this.
So tell me the next stages from here - how do you plan to take it one step forward?
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 9:48 am
by jamesd74
I would like to think we could get another cord progression.......
Put the two together if they don't fit another one and so on....
I was hoping as previously mentioned that Alun or Ricky might contribute..I will E-mail Alun see if I can get him interested....
Olly can you post you acoustic version that way Poly can work on that..
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 10:08 am
by Olly
I didn't save my acoustic version as the recording was so crap due to my mics not being set up for it. I will do so though, possibly not for the next couple of days due to my work schedule
Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 9:29 pm
by polyal
another part Bbsus2/// F/// Csus2/// ////
[mp3]/uploads/5b180513a542b42cc201a0baa1b7d7f4.mp3[/mp3]
sorry about the drummer
Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2012 7:47 am
by jamesd74
Yer it is starting to build now... I think we need another part after polys,,,
Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2012 10:51 pm
by alun
intro... C/Cmaj7 x 2
verse... C/Cmaj7/F/C/C/Cmaj7/F/C/C/Cmaj7/F/C/C/Cmaj7/F/C
chorus...F/G/F/C
Ends on... F/C x4
Hope this makes sense, it's the only way I know,
