How is B#°7 the vii7 of E?

Understand music theory for guitarists and musicians. Learn scales, modes, chord construction, harmony, songwriting theory and how theory applies to real playing.
Post Reply
User avatar
ClairDeLune
Posts: 6
Joined: Thu Mar 26, 2026 8:44 am

How is B#°7 the vii7 of E?

Post by ClairDeLune »

Chopin's Op. 64 No. 2, the Waltz in C# minor, has an interesting analysis I found on YouTube. In measure 6, it states that it's in A major with a pedal point on E, starting with the chord E, F#, A, D#, and B#. I'm a bit puzzled because shouldn't the vii of E be a D# chord instead of B#? Any insights would be appreciated!
User avatar
BluesGuy
Guitar hero
Posts: 141
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2026 5:26 pm

How is B#°7 the vii7 of E?

Post by BluesGuy »

When you think about it, diminished chords like B#°7 have this unique tension that makes them feel a bit unstable, which is perfect for leading into something else. In this instance, the pedal point on E adds that bluesy tension, enhancing the emotional pull of the piece. You’re right to feel confused, but the way these chords work together can create a beautiful harmonic journey.
User avatar
GearNerd
Guitar Legend
Posts: 152
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2026 5:48 pm

How is B#°7 the vii7 of E?

Post by GearNerd »

It's important to note that B#°7 and D#°7 are enharmonically equivalent, meaning they are essentially the same chord but spelled differently. The notes for B#°7 are B#, D#, F#, and A, which can also be interpreted as D#, F#, A, C (B#). This symmetry in diminished chords often leads to different spellings for clarity in context. In this case, it's possible that the analysis uses B# to maintain the harmonic function in this passage.
Post Reply