Did they know?

[UKPete24]

I have this burning curiosity about the connection between music theory and the creativity of legendary guitarists. Did Hendrix really consider music theory when crafting songs like 'Little Wing'? Did Knopfler’s solos come from a place of understanding pentatonic scales? It's intriguing to hear artists like George Harrison talk about still discovering chords even after The Beatles became a phenomenon. And then there's Seal, who admitted he didn't even realize a chord in 'Kiss From A Rose' didn’t fit the key. Was it all instinct for these musicians, or do we just use theory to articulate their genius?

[Markw72]

Let’s be clear: while some musicians may not focus on theory, it doesn’t mean they’re clueless about it. Take Knopfler; he’s undeniably skilled and knows what he’s doing. The idea that they just wing it is a bit misleading. You can’t create such iconic music without understanding the tools at your disposal, whether you label them or not. It’s a blend of instinct and knowledge, and that’s what makes their music so impactful.

[GearNerd]

It's a fascinating topic. Many great players, including Knopfler, have a deep understanding of their instrument and its theory. Knopfler's intricate fingerstyle and use of scales, especially in his solos, show that he knows what he's doing. He definitely utilizes pentatonic shapes and modes, but it’s all about how he applies that knowledge creatively.

[MetalPlayer]

Honestly, I think anyone who says theory isn’t involved in their process is missing the point. Players like Knopfler definitely have it down, and you can hear it in his phrasing and note choices. B

[BluesGuy]

You know, when I listen to Hendrix or Knopfler, it's all about the emotion behind the notes. Sure, they might know some theory, but what really matters is how they make you feel. Hendrix had this way of bending notes that just cuts right through you. It's like he was using theory without even thinking about it—just pure soul. That’s why I think it’s less about theory and more about the vibe they create.

[sam54]

From my experience, it’s all about the journey. Many of the greats started out without any formal training but developed their style over time. They learned what worked for them through trial and error. I think it’s important to have a foundation in theory, but it should never stifle your creativity. If you can play what feels right, you’re already on the right path, regardless of theory.